Tribune OnlineTribune OnlineTribune Online
  • Home
  • News
  • Columns
  • Editorial
  • VIDEOS
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Opinions
  • SPORTING TRIBUNE
Reading: There is nothing autonomous about artificial intelligence
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Tribune OnlineTribune Online
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • News
  • Columns
  • Editorial
  • VIDEOS
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Opinions
  • SPORTING TRIBUNE
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2026 African Newspapers of Nigeria Plc. All Rights Reserved. | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Editorial Policy | Corrections Policy | Terms & Conditions
Home » There is nothing autonomous about artificial intelligence
Latest News

There is nothing autonomous about artificial intelligence

Abisola Areola
September 25, 2025
Share
Add as a preferred source

Every time a company tells you its artificial intelligence works autonomously, somebody somewhere taught it what a human body looks like when it has been injured, and somebody else decided whether a photograph crossed a line.

Contents
  • What the Kenyan cases have actually established
  • The jobs are real. So is the precarity.
  • Why Nigeria should be paying attention
  • The argument that standards cost jobs, and why I think it is wrong
  • What that looks like in practice

A good deal of that work has been done in East and West Africa, by young graduates, for wages that would not cover a month’s rent in the cities where the companies are headquartered.

This is the part of the AI economy that does not appear in the pitch decks. Data labelling. Content moderation. Reinforcement learning from human feedback, which is the technical name for people correcting a model’s answers until it stops producing the wrong ones. Systems described as intelligent are, in significant part, systems that have been manually corrected at scale by people who were paid very little and told very little about what they were about to see.

We know what it costs them, because a court in Nairobi now has the evidence on file.

What the Kenyan cases have actually established

In December 2024, psychiatric evidence was submitted to Kenya’s Employment and Labour Relations Court by Dr Ian Kanyanya, head of mental health services at Kenyatta National Hospital. He had assessed 144 of the 185 former Facebook content moderators bringing the case. Eighty-one per cent of those he assessed had severe or extremely severe post-traumatic stress disorder. The diagnoses also included generalised anxiety disorder and major depressive disorder.

Their reported pay was around 429 dollars a month.

It is worth being precise about where these cases stand, because the reporting around them has been loose, and the detail matters more than the drama.

There are three separate actions. The first was brought in May 2022 by Daniel Motaung, a South African who was dismissed after organising a strike, alleging forced labour, union-busting and inadequate mental health support. The second, filed in March 2023, is the mass redundancy and blacklisting petition brought by 185 moderators. The third, the one carrying the widely quoted 1.6 billion dollar claim, is a different case altogether, concerning hate speech in Ethiopia, and it is routinely and wrongly attached to the moderators.

What the courts have decided so far is jurisdictional, and it is significant. Meta argued that Kenyan courts had no business hearing a claim against a company incorporated elsewhere and that the moderators were employed by its contractor rather than by it. In 2023, the court rejected that and treated Meta as the primary employer for the purposes of interim orders. In September 2024, the Court of Appeal dismissed Meta’s appeals as devoid of merit, confirming that it can be sued in Kenya. In April this year, the court ordered a senior Meta executive, its director of scaled regulatory response, to appear for cross-examination on an affidavit stating that Meta did not hire or fire moderators. Last month, Meta and its Irish entity were given twenty-one days to file their responses in the Motaung case.

No court has yet found Meta liable. Anyone telling you otherwise has read a headline rather than a judgement. What four years of litigation has established is narrower and, for the purposes of this argument, more useful: a client company’s contractual distance from the people doing its work is not, in a common-law African jurisdiction, a reliable shield.

The jobs are real. So is the precarity.

In April this year, Sama issued redundancy notices to 1,108 staff in Nairobi after Meta ended what the company described as a key engagement that it had tried and failed to retain.

Those jobs did not disappear because a model replaced them. They disappeared because one client changed its mind.

That is the characteristic danger of building an economy on being somebody else’s back office, and it is the third major job shock at that hub in three years. It should be read alongside the fact that the same company had already closed its content moderation arm in January 2023, cutting around 260 moderators, and refocused on annotation. The work does not vanish when a contract ends. It moves, and it changes its name.

Why Nigeria should be paying attention

Three reasons, and the first is the one nobody mentions.

Nigerians were part of this story from the beginning. The Nairobi moderation hub recruited across the continent. The African Content Moderators Union, formed in Nairobi in 2023, has a Nigerian chapter chaired by Kauna Malgwi, a clinical psychologist who moderated Hausa-language content for four years before founding a digital rights and mental health organisation. She was named to TIME’s hundred most influential people in artificial intelligence in 2024 and to the BBC’s hundred women in the same year, and TIME credits her advocacy with influencing European parliamentary work on platform labour. This is not a foreign dispute we are observing. Nigerians helped bring it.

The second reason is that Nigeria is now actively courting this category of work. Hire From Nigeria launched this year with government backing and a target of one million export-linked jobs by 2030, and our technology agency is pushing, rightly, for higher-value AI-enabled services rather than conventional outsourcing. But the realistic near-term demand from international buyers is not all high-value. A substantial share of it is annotation, labelling, moderation and model evaluation, which is to say the work Kenya has spent four years litigating.

The third reason is that our own legal protections for this work are untested. Nigerian labour law was not written with a graduate reviewing violent content to a quota in mind, and the question of whether work-related psychological injury is compensable here has not been seriously examined. We are recruiting into a category of work whose occupational hazard is a psychiatric one, without having decided what we owe the people doing it.

The argument that standards cost jobs, and why I think it is wrong

I understand the counterargument, because it is the argument that built our outsourcing sector. These are jobs. The country needs jobs. A formal contract with benefits in Lagos beats informal work in Lagos, and in a country where ninety-three per cent of employed people work informally, that is not a small thing. Sama says it pays living wages, and it has the independent engagement to point at. If we make demands, foreign firms will simply go elsewhere.

Two things make me think that argument is weaker than it looks.

The first is what happened when someone actually audited this work. The Fairwork project at the Oxford Internet Institute scored Sama zero out of ten in August 2023. By December, after engagement, the company had made twenty-four changes, including a guaranteed living wage, an end to unpaid overtime and longer contracts, and scored five. Fairwork’s more recent assessment puts it lower again, at three, which may reflect changed methodology and should be checked rather than assumed. But the direction of the first finding is the point. Standards in this sector are not economically impossible. They are simply not demanded.

The second is what the Kenyan rulings have done to the risk calculation. Every multinational buying this work now knows that a client can be pulled into a labour court in the jurisdiction where its supplier operates and that its executives can be ordered to testify. That changes what buyers want. A jurisdiction with clear standards, documented clinical support and lawful contracting is no longer the expensive option. It is the defensible one.

Protection has become a competitive feature. The first African country to understand that will take contracts from the ones still competing on cheapness and silence.

ALSO READ: Flávio Bolsonaro denies fleeing Brazil after landing in Miami

What that looks like in practice

Recognise content moderation and data annotation as hazardous work and regulate them accordingly. We already accept that certain occupations expose workers to harm and require specific protections. Reviewing the worst material the internet produces, for eight hours a day, to a quota, is such an occupation. Mandatory clinical support, exposure limits, and informed consent at recruitment are not radical asks. Eighty-one per cent severe PTSD in an assessed group is not an argument about workplace comfort.

Require transparency at the point of hiring. Several of the Kenyan claims turned on recruitment that did not make clear what the job actually involved. A young Nigerian answering an advertisement for a data role is entitled to know, before signing, whether it involves reviewing violent or sexual content.

Write client liability into procurement and investment agreements, rather than waiting for a Nigerian court to arrive at it the slow way, through the lives of the people it happened to.

Protect the right to organise. The union-busting allegation runs through all of this, and it is the easiest failure to repeat.

And diversify the buyer base deliberately. One thousand one hundred and eight people lost their jobs in Nairobi because of a single client decision. An impact sourcing strategy with one dominant customer is not a development strategy. It is a dependency with better branding.

None of this requires Nigeria to turn away the work. It requires us to take it on terms we would be willing to defend publicly, which is a lower bar than it sounds and one this industry has been allowed to duck for a decade.

There is nothing autonomous about artificial intelligence. There are only people, somewhere, doing the part the demonstration leaves out. Nigeria is about to employ a great many of them. The only question still open is on what terms.

Abisola Areola is a certified senior project manager and the founder of Skills Co-op, a cooperative social enterprise delivering free digital and AI skills training. She writes on AI, workforce intelligence, and the human layer that determines whether transformation works.


WATCH TOP VIDEOS FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE TV

  • Back to School, Back to Business A Fresh Start

  • Relationship Hangout: Public vs Private Proposals – Which Truly Wins in Love?

  • “No” Is a Complete Sentence: Why You Should Stop Feeling Guilty

  • Relationship Hangout: Friendship Talk 2025 – How to Be a Good Friend & Big Questions on Friendship

  • Police Overpower Armed Robbers in Ibadan After Fierce Struggle


    Get real-time news updates from Tribune Online! Follow us on WhatsApp for breaking news, exclusive stories and interviews, and much more.
    Join our WhatsApp Channel now


TAGGED:Artificial Intelligence (AI)autonomous
Previous Article UNICEF: 7.8 million children in Kano to get measles-rubella vaccine UNICEF lauds Sokoto govt for tackling child malnutrition
Next Article out-of-school children to Rep Kuye returns 200 out-of-school children to classrooms

Most Read

  • How to apply for FG's N100,000 family grant
    How to apply for FG's N100,000 family grant
  • TRENDING: JAMB, WAEC join UI, UNILAG, UNILORIN in master’s degree banter
    TRENDING: JAMB, WAEC join UI, UNILAG, UNILORIN in master’s degree banter
  • How to apply for FG’s N100m housing loans
    How to apply for FG’s N100m housing loans
  • 2027: Nigerians have lost confidence in Tinubu — Primate Ayodele
    2027: Nigerians have lost confidence in Tinubu — Primate Ayodele
  • ASUU to Tinubu: Release our withheld salaries now or risk fresh varsity crisis
    ASUU to Tinubu: Release our withheld salaries now or risk fresh varsity crisis
  • Reps halt cancellation of 2026 NCE, degree admissions by National Teachers’ Institute
    Reps halt cancellation of 2026 NCE, degree admissions by National Teachers’ Institute
  • 2027: Why Atiku is still ADC candidate despite court order — INEC
    2027: Why Atiku is still ADC candidate despite court order — INEC
  • Anthony Joshua welcomes baby girl
    Anthony Joshua welcomes baby girl
  • Ex-UNILAG VC to deliver convocation lecture as Anchor varsity graduates 563 students
    Ex-UNILAG VC to deliver convocation lecture as Anchor varsity graduates 563 students
  • Fountain of Life crisis: Jimmy Odukoya breaks silence on succession video, others
    Fountain of Life crisis: Jimmy Odukoya breaks silence on succession video, others

Frontpage Today

Subscribe to e-Paper

E-Vending, e paper, pdf, e-paper, Tribune
QUICK LINKS

About Us
Advertise with Us
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Disclaimer
Editorial Policy
Corrections Policy
Terms & Conditions
COLUMNS

Aplomb
Ask The Doctor
Autoclinic With The Mechanic
Awo's Thought
Empowered For Life
Festus Adedayo's Flickers
Tuesday Flat Out
Gibbers
Intimacy
Language & Style
Leadership & Management
Lynx Eye
Monday Lines
Mum & Child
Natural Health
Notes from Atlanta with Farooq Kperogi
On The Lord's Day
Your Life Counts

ENTERTAINMENT

Entertainment

RELIGION

Tribune Church
Church News
Muslim Sermon
Eye of Islam
Islamic News

EDITORIAL

Editorial
Opinion
Letters
News Extra

BUSINESS

Capital Market
Money Market

REGIONS

Niger Delta
Arewa
MORE

Sexuality & Health
Special Report
Sports
Tourism
Travelpulse & MICE
Weekend Lagos
Book Review
Education
Event Digest
Crime & Court
Ecoscope
Energy
Maritime
Aviation
Brands & Marketing
Agriculture
Info Tech
Labour
Leadership & Management
Arts & Culture
Arts & Reviews
Politics
Health News
© 2026 African Newspapers of Nigeria Plc. All Rights Reserved. | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Editorial Policy | Corrections Policy | Terms & Conditions

Add Tribune Online to your Homescreen!

Add
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?