By: Dr idowu Lateef oyeleke Esq
The Electric Power Sector Reform Act of 2005 codified the new legal and institutional framework for the power sector in Nigeria. After a decade of implementation of the EPSR Act 2005, the liberalization process remained stalled and mired in the challenges. Power shortages, operational challenges, low investment and under-exploitation of energy endowments are among the challenges. In view of the problems confronting the implementation of EPSR Act 2005, this study sought to analyse the legal and institutional framework of Electricity reforms in Nigeria and compare it with models in selected African countries and Emerging Economies. Other issues analysed are challenges and constraint, independence of regulators and overlapping functions of agencies in the power sector.
Qualitative and doctrinal methods were used in this study. The research questions were examined through investigations and comprehensive review of policies, legal and institutional framework for electricity sector reforms in Nigeria. Both primary and secondary sources were used generally, not necessarily in legalistic terms but in their practical sense and functional context. In order to draw experiences from other countries, where drawn to demonstrate particular areas of reform for Nigeria. From this study, it is concluded that the theoretical bases for the research using the theory of legal transplant, and attempt to balance the public and private interest theory of regulation justifies the study conducted in this research. therefore the conclusions that is drawn on the bases of the theoretical framework for the research is that importing the development from other jurisdiction without in the first instance seeking to prune them and apply them taking much cognizance of the Nigerian situation will not achieve the desired objective of the reform.
On the one hand, to dilemma exist for resolution in the electricity sector in Nigeria, public interest versus private interests. In pursuit of public interest by the government without much regard to the interest of the private sector, will be economically unrealistic and will in the same token score the government low in its policies to promote private investments. On the other hand, centering mainly on the interest of the private sector that are essentially moved to make profit will not be a politically realistic goal as that may be considered to be inimical to the interest of the citizens. Giving the current dilemma, the proposal for a balancing as enunciated in this study will be a way forward. The hybrid interest theory developed in this study, seeking to synergised the two conflicting interest and offer a win win situation for both the public and the private sector is the way forward.
This study found a number of legal and institutional problems that are capable of inhibiting the performance of the power sector in Nigeria. The analysis reveals that except the legal framework and institutions are well designed and critically structured in tune with the country political, economic and social status at the time of unbundling, the anticipated improvement and efficiency may be a mirage and the investment amount to a waste.
An x-ray of different provisions of the EPSR Act 2005 reveal a number of ambiguities and conflicting provisions with the constitution of FRN 1999, for example the provision of the constitution in second schedule part ii emphasized a decentralized power industry whereas the EPSR Act provides for its centralization, furthermore the ground norms specifically gives the National Assembly power to legislate on power generation and transmission and no more therefore any law that provides otherwise as can be found in the EPSR Act is an aberration and inconsistent, it is only state Houses of Assembly that are empowered to legislate on power distribution. The combine effect this law and by implication the model adopted should have been a horizontal unbundling as against the vertical approach adopted. It is found that the unprecedented success recorded in most of the emerging economics investigated were product of careful adoptions of models that reflect the local peculiarities of their state.
ALSO READ: BYERA, BYEDC/PHED meet to resolve consumers’ electricity issues
Lack of adequate implementation of the power sector reforms couple with overlapping of agencies functions and interference in the operation of the regulating agencies account for failure of the electric power reforms in Nigeria. The inability to develop pricing schemes that strike a better balance between economic efficiency and social equity remain a big challenge. IPP have been an important source of new investment in many developing countries, in most of the country investigated, the introduction of IPP has led to a big increase in generating capacity. Moreover an IPP scheme is contingent on a coherent policy framework that pays explicit attention to planning, procurement and contracting issues. The successful outcome of any reform is predicated on effective regulatory governance (characterized by coherence, independence, accountability, transparency, predictability and capacity). Effective regulatory oversight can lead to lower capacity cost as well as to improved operating efficiencies.
The gab in the literature which this work seek to bridge is the issue of the disconnection between the policy in the oil and gas industry without reference or relationship or recognize the relevant provisions of the EPSRA, for example the PPA provides for exclusive purchase of bulk power from GENCO to NBET Plc. and for bulk sales to DISCO. A close analysis of some of the provisions of EPSR Act 2005 shows numbers of ambiguities and inconsistencies and lacuna. These among other factor account for difficulties in implementation and adherence more in disobedience than compliance by the stakeholders. The emerging facts from the study shows that lack of adequate implementation of the reform, weak institutions couple with overlapping functions and interference in the operation of the regulatory agencies, and more importantly over dependence on gas for power generation which almost always are in short supply are some of the factors that account for the inefficacy in Electric power sector post reforms.
When the policy, legal and institutional framework is well designed and implemented in proper sequence, a combination of institutional reforms, vertical and horizontal restructuring, privatization, and effective regulation (particularly incentive-based regulation) would lead to significant improvements in operating performance, in power sector reform in Nigeria this is achievable when adequate attention is paid to local peculiarities of the reforming country such as political, social and economic status of the country before unbundling.
There is a strong link between good and credible regulation and the objective of securing foreign direct investment and privately financed investment more generally because the investor confidence would be guaranteed and feel secured, while delivering efficient service at sustainable, just and reasonable prices. As a consequence of the reforms, retail prices have become more closely aligned with underlying costs, and cross-subsidies have been reduced and in some countries eliminated. There is a logical sequence of reforms, and undertaking reforms in the wrong order is costly. Ideally, reforming countries should first raise prices to cost-recovering levels (with a return on capital to finance investment), then create regulatory institutions and restructure the sector, and only after that privatize.
Shortage of gas supply has continuously hindered the availability of new gas-fired power stations to generate electricity in sufficient quantities. The lack of a gas pricing framework represents a major hurdle that needs to be crossed. Gas supply is also affected by inadequate gas transportation infrastructure. There needs to be a full implementation of the gas master plan to ensure the adequate supply.
The gas stations should be located close to the IPP thermal stations this would not only reduce the risk of pipeline vandalism but also drastically reduce the cost of transportation. It is also important that there should be a paradigm shift in government policy from commercialization of oil and gas to gas to power generation. Finally, the long-standing problems of poor performance at the transmission and distribution end, however, remain as intractable as ever. One of the reasons for this state of affairs can be linked to the excessive emphasis placed on increased generation when a significant proportion of problems facing power sector utilities in Nigeria can be traced to transmission and distribution.
Both vertical and horizontal unbundling should have been more suitable for the country in view of its geographical arrangement and each of the 36 state should have been encouraged to set up its state electric electricity regulatory commission (SERC) as suggested by the 1999 constitution, for more effective regulation, efficiency and strong institution. We can therefore argue without modicum of doubt that reforms have largely targeted the easiest part of the problem, namely, addition of new generation capacity when attention should have been focused on the transmission and distribution sides of the electricity industry.
Consequently, a strong case can be made that any future reform measures should primarily address the challenges that still face the transmission and distribution chain in electric power sector because no amount of capacity build at the generation side of electricity production, if the infrastructure at transmission and distribution is not upgraded to a relatively high level, the effort would amount to a waste. The government should continue to ensure that the reform in the power sector should be more focused and the interest of both the private sector are harnessed and stable legal and institutional framework that will stand the test of time should be attained. That is the obvious way that the lights in Nigeria can be kept on without the country continuing in perpetual blackouts.
WATCH TOP VIDEOS FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE TV
- Relationship Hangout: Public vs Private Proposals – Which Truly Wins in Love?
- “No” Is a Complete Sentence: Why You Should Stop Feeling Guilty
- Relationship Hangout: Friendship Talk 2025 – How to Be a Good Friend & Big Questions on Friendship
- Police Overpower Armed Robbers in Ibadan After Fierce Struggle


