Tribune OnlineTribune OnlineTribune Online
  • Home
  • News
  • Columns
  • Editorial
  • VIDEOS
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Opinions
  • SPORTING TRIBUNE
Reading: COP28 and quest for climate justice
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Tribune OnlineTribune Online
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • News
  • Columns
  • Editorial
  • VIDEOS
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Opinions
  • SPORTING TRIBUNE
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2026 African Newspapers of Nigeria Plc. All Rights Reserved. | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Editorial Policy | Corrections Policy | Terms & Conditions
Home » COP28 and quest for climate justice
ECOSCOPE

COP28 and quest for climate justice

Paul Omorogbe
December 21, 2023
Share
Nnimmo Bassey release of GMOs COP28
Add as a preferred source

At the Nigerian Resource Justice Conference 2023 hosted by Social Action and Corporate Accountability and Public Participation Africa (CAPPA) on December 18, 2023 in Abuja Nnimmo Bassey, Director of Health of Mother Earth Foundation (HOMEF), in a paper, said a reliance on Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) in climate negotiations promotes climate injustice. PAUL OMOROGBE brings excerpts:

The reliance on NDCs locks in inequality and injustice in the entire climate negotiation process. With this understanding, my initial conclusion is that COPs conducted on an unjust basis will continue to yield hollow outcomes that at best scratch the surface of the climate crisis.

The foundation for voluntary emissions cut by nations was laid in the Copenhagen Accord (2009) and consolidated in the Paris Agreement (2015) under what is known as Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs). This voluntary mechanism essentially blunted the Common But Differentiated Responsibilities (CBDR), a cardinal justice principle of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change UNFCCC.

Whereas in the past, rich, industrialized and polluting nations were grouped as Annex 1 nations and had binding emissions reduction requirements, under the NDCs, there are no binding obligations. Nations simply have to do what is convenient for them to do and report back on what they have done to the Conference of Parties (COP). Such submissions were made for the global stocktake at the United Nations Climate Conference (COP28) in Dubai this year.

Voluntary emissions reduction can work in a situation where there is no crisis and no urgency for action. However, the world has already progressed from global warming to global heating and the prognosis for the future shows very dire situations. The evidence of the trend is presented in the various Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reports as well as in United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP)’s Emissions Gap Report (EGR).

The EGR issued just before COP28 showed that rather than reducing, global greenhouse emissions increased by 1.2 per cent from 2021 to 2022 to reach a new record of 57.4 gigatonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent. In addition, an aggregation of the NDCs proposed by nations showed that the world was heading for a 2.5 to 2.9C temperature increase above pre-industrial level. At that temperature level, there will be a spike in freak weather events and the overall conditions will make parts of the world uninhabitable.

The reliance on NDCs locks in inequality and injustice in the entire climate negotiation process. With this understanding, my initial conclusion is that COPs conducted on an unjust basis will continue to yield hollow outcomes that at best scratch the surface of the climate crisis.

 

Fossil notice

COP28 has three significant accomplishments, but around each are bubbles of uncertainties and loopholes. The three highlights are the adoption of Loss and Damage Fund mechanism, the agreement to triple renewables capacity and double energy efficiency by 2030, and the agreement to transition away from fossil fuels in energy.

Yet, in all, the real winners are the army of fossil fuels lobbyists and the petrostates. After kicking and screening for decades, the COP finally agreed to acknowledge that burning of fossil fuels must end. The phrase of transitioning from fossil fuels for energy was so carefully crafted it leaves an ocean-wide space for the fossil fuel industries to keep on prospecting for, and extracting the resources.

The restriction of the open-ended transition to renewable energy gives the industry the space to keep drilling for production of plastics, petrochemicals and diverse products. In other words, that celebrated clause does give a lifeline for the petroleum civilisation to trudge on.

 

Carbon wordsmiths

The wordsmiths of the COP play with the imagination of the world and it is time to wake up to this fact. At COP26 the phrase “phase down” instead of “phase out” was introduced. A phasing down of coal, for example, simply indicates there would be some efforts to tinker with production and consumption volumes of the hydrocarbon. It does not by any stretch suggest halting dependence of the dirty energy source.

A lot of energy was spent at COP27 and COP28 to push for the “phase out” language in the outcome documents. The draft outcome document of COP28 particularly gave a number of options on how the language for “phasing out fossil fuels” could be couched.

While negotiators and politicians tried to wrap their heads around the clause, which would remain a clear ending of the fossil fuels age, the wordsmiths came out with “transitioning from fossil fuels in energy.”

So, there is the phase down, phase out and then a partial transition. Strikingly, the document also highlights the continued role of transition fuels―a clear reference to fossil gas.

 

Carbon speculators

Whereas there was no agreement on adopting a UN sanctioned mechanism for carbon trading, aspects of Article 6 of the Paris Agreement opened the floodgates for carbon capture and utilisation and storage, carbon dioxide removals and variants of geoengineering.

Carbon capture introduces the notion of pollution abatement – an interesting term. While it is clear that the best action is to stop pollution at source, various COPs say keep polluting, but capture the pollution before it escapes into the environment. If it doesn’t work, all the polluter needs to do is to show that it is sucking or removing the errant carbon from the atmosphere.

The carbon market business has been a speculator’s paradise, with scant transparency or integrity. This state of play allowed carbon cowboys and dealers to trade in phantom carbon or even forests, leaving investors in limbo.

With the matter now rolling over to COP29, observers now wonder if the tide of land and forest trading desks across Africa would be stemmed.

In the run up to COP28, there were reports of deals aimed at selling off huge swathes of African territories to be utilised as carbon sinks. There are reports of nations inking memoranda of understanding or agreements to cede huge segments of their territories for carbon credits. Zimbabwe has put 20% of its forests on the chopping block, Zambia and Liberia are extending 10% while Tanzania is said to offer 8 million hectares of forest.

Nigeria’s Niger State offered to sell 760,000 hectares of land to Blue Carbon, a UAE carbon focused company, for afforestation programme that would see the planting of one billion trees.

The thing to note is that the lands or forests are not sold in perpetuity. The leases have stipulated years over which the investor would find ways of securing the carbon in the land, sea or forest. They could also engage in carbon farming through, for example, clearing the territory and then creating a tree plantation which should be seen as a colonial euphemism for monoculture cash cropping. The investor farms carbon and owns the credit accruing from there.

The investor can use the carbon to offset his polluting activity at home and can even sell off some to help others offset their polluting activities. The investor can count a carbon sink in Africa as part of their Nationally Determined Contributions actions.  The country that sold its territory may not do so.

 

Climate justice

Having climate justice in quotes says a lot about the mindset of the nations with regard to the disproportionate climate change impact on vulnerable communities, territories and nations. The COP26 outcome document did not place climate justice in quotes, but added that it was only important to some. In other words, climate justice is not something of universal concern. COP28 avoided that blatant disregard of the Common but Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities (CBDR-RC), a clear climate justice principle in the climate convention.

In keeping with the general wordsmithing approach of the COPs, the principle and reality was now placed in harmless quotes.

READ ALSO FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE 

  • Ailing Chief Kokori dies on 80th birthday
  • Revenue: Stop tax waivers, offer rebates, Senate tells FG
  • Sports minister meets NFF, Peseiro over AFCON plans
  • Kaduna bombing: Fresh twist as protesters demand resignation of Defence Minister
  • No money voted to renovate my residence – Gbajabiamila
  • PRESSTIME PODCAST: Digital Media, social media, where do we draw the line

 


WATCH TOP VIDEOS FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE TV

  • Back to School, Back to Business A Fresh Start

  • Relationship Hangout: Public vs Private Proposals – Which Truly Wins in Love?

  • “No” Is a Complete Sentence: Why You Should Stop Feeling Guilty

  • Relationship Hangout: Friendship Talk 2025 – How to Be a Good Friend & Big Questions on Friendship

  • Police Overpower Armed Robbers in Ibadan After Fierce Struggle


    Get real-time news updates from Tribune Online! Follow us on WhatsApp for breaking news, exclusive stories and interviews, and much more.
    Join our WhatsApp Channel now


TAGGED:ClimateCOP28JusticeQuest
Previous Article Who is after Professor Fasina Beyond Ramadan What matters going forward Omooba Doyin Okupe, FG’s e-border project: An outsider’s view, Tobacco industry's deadly Warri Refinery, VP Shettima’s ill-advised Kemi Badenoch IDPs in the North, Which group is Egbe Omo Eko social welfare reform, NIS 2024 Comptroller-General conference, South-West’s real estate market, Maolud Nabiyyi, purchasing power in Nigeria, Russia got to do with it, Tinubu’s speech a show of leadership and Nigeria’s democracy through strong judiciary, extortion at airports, Helping neonates communicate beyond crying, Between Nigeria and the world, Passionate appeal to Oyo State govt 2023 review: Tunji-Ojo’s strides as Interior minister
Next Article NCF NCF harps on training of youths, students on environmental protection

Most Read

  • 2027: Nigerians have lost confidence in Tinubu — Primate Ayodele
    2027: Nigerians have lost confidence in Tinubu — Primate Ayodele
  • UniAbuja sold land to individuals, corporate bodies, EFCC — FCTA 
    UniAbuja sold land to individuals, corporate bodies, EFCC — FCTA 
  • NURTW gives Oyo govt seven-day ultimatum to end PMS operation across parks
    NURTW gives Oyo govt seven-day ultimatum to end PMS operation across parks
  • Fountain of Life Church removes Jimmy Odukoya as senior pastor
    Fountain of Life Church removes Jimmy Odukoya as senior pastor
  • Fountain of Life Church appoints Rotimi Okpaise as interim leader
    Fountain of Life Church appoints Rotimi Okpaise as interim leader
  • Tinubu and the children of anger from the North
    Tinubu and the children of anger from the North
  • Tinubu offers Nigerians N100m housing loans
    Tinubu offers Nigerians N100m housing loans
  • Ex-UNILAG VC to deliver convocation lecture as Anchor varsity graduates 563 students
    Ex-UNILAG VC to deliver convocation lecture as Anchor varsity graduates 563 students
  • FG to stop air passengers without NIN from flying, January 1
    FG to stop air passengers without NIN from flying, January 1
  • UPDATED: Jimmy Odukoya’s remarriage contradicts our teachings — Fountain of Life Church
    UPDATED: Jimmy Odukoya’s remarriage contradicts our teachings — Fountain of Life Church

Frontpage Today

Subscribe to e-Paper

E-Vending, e paper, pdf, e-paper, Tribune
QUICK LINKS

About Us
Advertise with Us
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Disclaimer
Editorial Policy
Corrections Policy
Terms & Conditions
COLUMNS

Aplomb
Ask The Doctor
Autoclinic With The Mechanic
Awo's Thought
Empowered For Life
Festus Adedayo's Flickers
Tuesday Flat Out
Gibbers
Intimacy
Language & Style
Leadership & Management
Lynx Eye
Monday Lines
Mum & Child
Natural Health
Notes from Atlanta with Farooq Kperogi
On The Lord's Day
Your Life Counts

ENTERTAINMENT

Entertainment

RELIGION

Tribune Church
Church News
Muslim Sermon
Eye of Islam
Islamic News

EDITORIAL

Editorial
Opinion
Letters
News Extra

BUSINESS

Capital Market
Money Market

REGIONS

Niger Delta
Arewa
MORE

Sexuality & Health
Special Report
Sports
Tourism
Travelpulse & MICE
Weekend Lagos
Book Review
Education
Event Digest
Crime & Court
Ecoscope
Energy
Maritime
Aviation
Brands & Marketing
Agriculture
Info Tech
Labour
Leadership & Management
Arts & Culture
Arts & Reviews
Politics
Health News
© 2026 African Newspapers of Nigeria Plc. All Rights Reserved. | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Editorial Policy | Corrections Policy | Terms & Conditions

Add Tribune Online to your Homescreen!

Add
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?