Introduction
Prop firms, which are formally recognised as proprietary trading firms, have initiated a unique gateway for new traders to penetrate into the market by offering them necessary capital with zero or little personal risk involved. This innovative yet questionable approach has granted prominence to proprietary trading and the firms involved, especially as it contradicts the traditional broking process that requires traders, whether new or seasoned, to use their personal funds for investment. However, taking a closer look at the prop trading business model, one would find how it’s designed contemptuously with complex approaches suffered by novice traders. Prop firms require these novice traders to acquire “challenge accounts,” as a prerequisite before they are granted capital to start up their personal trades. These challenge accounts are processed under strict conditions, requiring several evaluation stages before traders can be granted real money.
While new traders may consider utilizing prop firms because of the on-the-job learning opportunity it provides, the value of the model raises concerns especially since more than half of novice traders who get involved always walk away with empty pockets because of low success rates. New traders are often victims of prop firm’s harsh realities because of their undying quest to trade even when they have insufficient capital. This article therefore assesses the suitability rate, benefits, and limitations of prop firms as a platform for novice traders to utilize, particularly focused on the business model and the long-term implications it has for novice traders. It combines statistical references and unique case studies to explore whether prop firms support or hamper the trading skills for beginners.
Understanding Proprietary Trading
Following the principles guiding the financial parlance, proprietary trading is an institution or firm’s effort to trade for itself, amassing direct gains. This is usually exerted through unique strategies that involve employing novice traders to trade for them while they cover most of the funding and risk involved. It has grown to become a powerhouse in the financial industry, having strongholds on newbie traders whose naive minds are set on making profits and trading without personal risk, incapable of weighing the implications involved.
Prop firms allow novices to trade their capital in exchange for shared profits, which puts the traders at lower risk. This design doesn’t often play out the way it seems, as most prop firms demand that novice traders adopt challenge accounts, which are demo-driven accounts filled with virtual coins. A novice trader may spend nearly all his personal savings to adopt a demo account of say, $10,000, where at the end of the day, majority of them don’t scale through the evaluation stages before they are granted real capital for personal investments.
The model demands very stressful deadlines from traders including meeting up with drawdown limits, and the movement from one evaluation stage to another in order to qualify for a real funded account. The business model is highly profitable for prop firm’s because almost 98% of these traders fail to pass evaluation stages, and retain the fees paid by these traders in acquiring a challenge account, despite the agreement of 80% shared profit.
Prop trading differs from traditional brokerages that allow new traders to risk their funds on investment when they aren’t as knowledgeable to navigate the uncertainties that come with the market. The weight of the requirement in prop trading lies in the compulsory high-pressure tasks mounted on traders in compliance with risk management parameters, drawdown limits, and protective exits. Through prop trading, there’s high penetration rates in the market, and while this might seem like growth, it encourages the intent of manipulation, especially through social trading platforms.
Despite the growth and opportunities prop trading presents, the model raises concerns about the ethics of exploiting novice traders, who possess little skills to excel under the model’s work dynamic but are lured because of the promise of high rewards. Proprietary trading calls for the check of suitability and sustainability rate in the industry, particularly as it’s believed that the desperation and naivety of novice traders to being in the market are negatively exploited.
Prop Trading: Benefits for Novice Traders
Access to Capital
The major, if not the most obvious, benefit of prop trading practiced by firms is the offering of investment capital to novice traders. This capital comes with knowledgeable kits and tools that will aid a deepened trading experience. This is particularly appealing to the traders who believe that their personal capital is too small to perform well in the market, hence, would lead to failure. While in the actual sense these traders can actually personally fund accounts with twice the capital they invest in the fees for obtaining challenge accounts.
Exposure to Professional Environments
Novice traders are somewhat new to trading and might have only little experience in trading, probably attuned to a particular platform or asset. However, with prop firms, novice traders are established and launched into professional trading environments that afford them the opportunity to get mentored and have access to leading technologies relevant in today’s world of trading. Opportunities like this are hard to come by with traditional broking processes; hence, it becomes highly invaluable for novices who constantly develop the technical and analytical skills needed for high-stakes trading. A Chicago-based prop firm conducted a survey and found out that 80% of its trainees and prop traders developed their skills in technical analysis through training and real-time feedback while trading for the firm. Experiences like this elevate beginners, ushering them to gaining a balance into the trading profession in full.
Profit Potential
The prop trading model is designed to share profits generated from trades between firms and traders. These earnings usually fall between 50% and 80% of the overall profit generated, depending on the kind of agreement made and the measure of the trading performance. This structure creates an attractive reward system, which lures not even novice traders but seasoned traders who are hit by economic downsides to hop into partnerships.
Prop Trading: Challenges for Novice Traders
Strict Risk Management Rules
Risk management for trading is very important, especially for non-diversified portfolios, but in prop trading, firms impose strict routines that control and protect the flow of capital. These routines may include positioning limits, where maximum limits on individual trades are set against high concentrations of a single asset. There’s also value at risk (VaR) analysis, where the expected loss of a trade is measured over a period of time, helping firms control intending risk under normal circumstances. Stress testing, scenario analysis, leverage limits, and many others.
These are all good risk management approaches, but they become too cumbersome for novice traders to operate almost all at once. Prop Capital Analysts in 2020 embarked on a study to investigate firms leveraging strict risk management policies, and data from the study shows that about 90% of prop firms maximize risk management policies, resulting in a 2% rate of capital per trade. The limitations these risk management policies present overwhelm novice traders, declining them the opportunity to experiment and learn through mistakes. The study also finds that only 25% of novice traders stick through with prop firms after the evaluation stages, which don’t exceed three months. This indicates the degree of stress prop firms impose on novice traders.
Psychological Stress and Burnout
The management of trades in large volumes might be mentally daunting, especially for novices whose trading experience isn’t grown enough to overcome the stress that the process presents. The traders are likely to get exhausted since they are required to work with targets, creating the pressure to meet expectations. A prop firm found that over 60% of its partnered novice traders reported increased rates of stress and fatigue within three months of evaluation stages. This strain is psychological and has tendencies to corrupt not just performance but also the overall well-being of novice traders.
Financial Dependence on Short-Term Gains
The prop trading model prioritizes trades for short-term profits. The integration of novice traders in this cycle declines attempts at sustainable trading culture for long-term benefits. Traders might garner a few smart trading cues while in tandem with risk management measures to yield profit from trades, which doesn’t equate to actual trading development—understanding scopes and full-circle strategies that can be adopted for different markets. Trading Times’ survey revealed that over 70% of novice traders are mostly focused on short-term earnings without considering reinvesting for long-term trading. The Prop trading model breeds short-term traders who can be easily considered quacks and threats in the financial landscape because they lack the ability to be versatile and innovative towards sustaining the trading profession.
High Failure Rates in Challenges
Perhaps one of the most prominent drawbacks of prop trading is the high rate of failures from novice traders during the evaluation stages. They fail to meet up the target set by prop firms because of strict trading environments and unhealthy expectations. Novice traders end up losing their challenge account fees without securing a funded account that launches them in full into trading. This reveals the high sense of risk prop trading subjects novice traders who are mostly at the losing end.
Suitability of Prop Firms for Skill Development
Without doubt, prop firms offer great opportunities for novice traders to learn, become exposed, and grow in financial markets; however, they’re not suitable for skill development. While some firms operate on a designed structure to mentor and train novice traders on the job, the criteria to keep up with the training usher in limitations as a result of intense regulatory demands. A lot of novice traders battle with lack of thorough insight, confidence, and job security due to the short-term driven goals of prop firms, which are major components of distortion for learning.
Seasoned traders hold the belief that it’s best novice traders who are yet to understand the nitty-gritty of the trading world consider trading using small amounts as startup capital whilst they participate in learning programs online that could offer gradual yet substantial knowledge to navigate trading environments. This, according to seasoned traders, is believed to provide a more thriving environment for skill development. Markets Education Limited carried out an analysis in 2023 on novice traders, and it’s found that over 60% of traders who had practiced trading with self-capital prior to prop trading perform better than those without independent trading experience. This suggests that independent trading experience is a crucial foundation for long-term success.
Long-Term Career Implications
Prop trading doesn’t offer quality long-term implications because of its hasty nature to realize profit. However, a few novice traders scale through the rigorous process, and in most cases, it transcends them to higher opportunities in advanced roles such as senior financial managers and other top-paying roles. The novice traders who couldn’t stand the strenuous cycle fall off and, in most cases, find it difficult to find their feet in the industry when there’s no self-capital, as they are left with little skills, no expertise, and no carved niche. The career implications of prop trading on a long-term basis are bleak for most cases; however, it depends on individuals and how they plan to elevate their performances despite present constraints.
Conclusion
Proprietary trading firms are like a double-edged sword; they provide a thriving trading environment for novice traders with promises of shared profits but in this provided environment lies heavy trading conditions that often impedes the success of these novice traders. They are exposed to high failure rates, psychological burnout and miss out the organic knowledge expected to be learned during a trading process. This entire process presents prop trading as a risky venture, hence, novice traders should be careful while considering alternative routes to the market by taking a critical analysis on the structures of firms. More importantly, novice traders should enroll in educational programs that can impact true trading knowledge from scratch in order to build an independent and strong foundation for long-term success, because while prop trading may serve as a path to live out short-term goals, a grounded skill is needed for sustained career level.
Temitope George Ijibadejo is an award-winning Forex fund manager with over 15 years of experience as a Forex fund manager, business developer consultant and trainer in Forex trading
ALSO READ TOP STORIES FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE
and then