“Cattle farming are private owned businesses, the responsibility for which should be borne by the owners and not the other way round”.
LAST WEEK, I commenced a discussion on the menace of criminal herdsmen who continue to pose major security challenges. Also, I discussed the attempt by the Nigerian government to placate the herders by the subtle suggestion of acquisition of massive lands all over Nigeria for grazing, a move which will no doubt create more chaos as it will engender the acquisition of private lands to satisfy the spatial requirement for grazing ranches. It is however important to note that the clashes brought about by open grazing is not limited to Nigeria. Similar clashes have occurred in other African Countries. In examining the development across West Africa, the Cable, an online publication wrote as follows:
Eighteen killed in Niger
In November 2016, eighteen people were killed in various clashes between herdsmen and farmers. The clash, which broke out near the village of Bangui along the country’s southern border with Nigeria, also left 20 others injured, the country’s officials had said.
What happened? Livestock belonging to the herders were said to have invaded the field of one of the farmers, damaging crops.
“The nomadic herders fought with a farmer, whom they wounded. He was taken to the medical centre and everything started from there,” Oumarou Mohamane, Bangui’s mayor, had told Reuters.
In a reprisal attack, a group of farmers then attacked the camp, burning down houses numbering about 15.
Villages in the Kwahu east district of the eastern region of Ghana were thrown into mourning after clashes between herdsmen and some of their farmers left a reported number of 15 persons dead, including five Fulanis.
Hundreds were also left stranded and displaced after fleeing their communities in the incident which occurred in November.
The clashes, which were between residents of Dwibease and Hweehwe, and the herders, followed the death of an unidentified boy at Dwerebeafe.
Solomon Aboagye, an indigene, was quoted by Ghana Web, an online platform, to have said: “In retaliation, three of the Fulanis were also killed at Aboyan.
“Two of the natives went to the farm and did not return. I asked some people to search for them and unfortunately, they found them dead.”
It was also reported that the deaths occurred at night in the farms and the bodies spotted daytime.
BLOODSHED IN IVORY COAST
Seventeen persons were confirmed dead and 39 others injured after a clash broke out between herdsmen and farmers in Bouna, north-east of Ivory Coast, in 2016.Among those injured in the clash, which spanned two days, were five of the security personnel deployed to quell the crisis.The attack was said to be just one out of many other violent clashes between the two parties “but none has been of this magnitude”.“On the night of March 23 to 24, the situation was particularly aggravated and it was at this time that 17 people died,” Vincent Toh Bi, one of the residents, had told AfricaNews.
Indeed, some contend that clashes between herdsmen or cattle herders and farmers are as old as mankind itself as indicated by the biblical verse in the book of Exodus Chapter 22 verse 5 which enjoins anyone who allows his animal to stray and graze in the field of another to pay compensation to that other. What is however clear is that while mankind, inclusive of many African countries have developed policies aimed at reducing the conflict, Nigeria is yet to come up with any identifiable means of bring about peaceful co-existence between farmers and herdsmen.
Rethinking the incidence of open grazing
There is no doubt that there is an urgent need by the Nigerian government to resolve the issue of open grazing once and for all. One of the ways to deal with the matter is to encourage large-scale farming by the cattle owners. The US has led the world in large-scale farming, pioneering the use of intensive livestock rearing in hog farms, cattle sheds and sheep pens. There are now more than 50,000 facilities in the US classified as “concentrated animal feeding operations” (CAFOs), with another quarter of a million industrial-scale facilities below that threshold.
Around the world, developing countries in particular were quick to catch up. Intensive farming of livestock offers many advantages over traditional open ranges, not least in the economies of cost and scale, it provides more efficient healthcare for the herds and flocks, and ultimately cheaper food. According to the UN, globally CAFOs account for 72% of poultry, 42% of egg, and 55% of pork production. Instead of the present itinerant method of grazing prominent in Nigeria, owners of cattle should acquire or lease land for the purpose of grazing. However rather than directly foot the bill for development of such large-scale farming, all that the government should do is to make loans available to cattle owners and other farmers. The Punch newspaper editorial was quite detailed in pointing that as the Federal Government did with the Anchor Borrowers Programme for rice, it should facilitate such loans for cattle farmers. Such loans would be used to buy land in their states of choice.
In Brazil, government has grown to become a major player in the meat business and the country’s foreign trade secretariat states that from an income of $1.9m in 1994, beef export income of the country risen to $1.9bn in 2004, providing 360,000 direct jobs as the records show. What the country does is to aid the business by facilitating low-interest loans to farmers.
In Spain, livestock farming is intensive, with animals living on farms and consuming fodder and this practice became further entrenched following the country’s admission into the European Union, which caused the country to change some of its agricultural practices. The country received significant economic assistance from the EU to modernise the sector, increase productivity and improve the quality of its products.
In Argentina, the practice is not any different. Livestock farming as a form of agriculture is aimed with increased productivity and modernity at the base of its practice. The role of government differs slightly from country to country but it is poignant to note government’s intervention is limited to making available assistance in terms of roving loans at low interest rate and regulated policies and not for government to undertake financial burdens as being suggested in government quarters.
In Botswana, the country’s beef and cattle farming has grown exponentially from a few hundred thousand cattle in 1950 to close to three million today. The growth is traceable to deliberate government’s policies which averted this kind of crisis currently rocking the middle belt and southern region with occasional flares in other parts of the country with mindless deaths and destructions in its wake.
In conclusion, the dangers inherent in the government’s proposal are numerous to say the least. It is brazenly discriminatory and offensive to common sense, law and good judgement. How can a purely private business become the burden of a central government or constitute a menace to other private citizens? Cattle farming are private owned businesses, the responsibility for which should be borne by the owners and not the other way round. Examples suggested in the above listed countries of how their governments have handled potentially intractable issues can be imbibed here. Borrowing from all that, government in Nigeria should encourage herders to acquire lands and modernise their practice in conformity with global best practices.
YOU SHOULD NOT MISS THESE HEADLINES FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE
Nigeria recorded a slight reduction in the number of COVID-19 infections, recoveries and deaths last week, Tribune Online analysis shows. Last week (February 14 to 20), 5,849 new cases were reported in the country, the lowest in seven weeks. The last time Nigeria recorded such a low figure was in the December 27 to January 2 week, when it reported 5,681 cases…
The Federal Government is owing the university workers, under the National Association of Academic Technologists (NAAT), the Senior Staff Association of Nigerian Universities (SSANU) and the Non-Academic Union of Universities and Associated Institutions (NASU), over N150 billion earned allowances…
“Please do not talk to my father. He is yet to come to terms with the death of his son. It is a most tragic experience. How does one quantify the loss of a dear brother? My brother was killed like an animal by two herdsmen. His offence was that he asked them to drive their cows off his already cultivated farmland,” Bisi Olaosepin, whose brother was hacked to death, struggled to hold back his tears as he relayed to Sunday Tribune the horrible experience that culminated in the passage of his brother…
Rays of the afternoon sun pelted her head as she fanned the embers beneath the half-cut iron drum with the smoke permeating the air. “This smoke is unbearable, Iya Maria,” said one of the three neighbours conversing under a makeshift shed about five meters away. Their voices rose and fell intermittently…
Vice President Yemi Osinbajo has admonished that despite differences in religion, ethnicity, political affiliations, or other diversities, Nigerians of all generations and from all walks of life must endeavour to commit to ensuring Nigeria’s unity because the nation is stronger together than apart…