This analysis by Abuja Bureau Chief, LEON USIGBE, delves into the key aspects of President Bola Tinubu’s agenda, evaluating its merits, demerits, controversial elements, and the projected outlook for 2025.
President Bola Tinubu’s administration argues that its reform agenda represents a comprehensive attempt to address Nigeria’s economic challenges through fiscal and structural adjustments. While supporters hail these measures as necessary for revitalizing the economy, critics warn of potential negative consequences. Encapsulated in the Renewed Hope Agenda, the reform focuses on a structured plan addressing critical socio-economic issues, including food security, economic growth, job creation, access to capital, inclusion, rule of law, and combating corruption.
The government asserts that the agenda will restore citizens’ trust in governance by addressing the root causes of Nigeria’s challenges and fostering a more prosperous, secure, and equitable future. It emphasizes the need for commitment from government officials and civil servants, indicating that success depends on collective effort and accountability.
Criticisms
Among the most controversial measures are the removal of fuel subsidies and rising taxes, which have intensified economic challenges, including inflation and increased poverty levels. Critics argue that these measures disproportionately impact low- and middle-income citizens, undermining the social contract.
Despite widespread outcry, President Tinubu has pushed forward with Tax Reform Bills aimed at harmonizing multiple taxes into a single levy, reducing bureaucratic hurdles, and enhancing compliance. By lowering the overall tax burden, the administration argues that these measures will stimulate business activities, particularly for struggling enterprises. The theory behind the reforms posits that improved compliance and a broader tax base could significantly increase government revenue, enabling investments in public services. Revenue diversification is critical to reducing Nigeria’s dependence on oil and cushioning the economy against volatile global oil prices.
Key promises
The government has introduced tax exemptions for low-income earners and essential goods to reduce financial pressure on economically disadvantaged Nigerians. By targeting relief efforts, the administration hopes to minimize the reform’s adverse effects on vulnerable populations.
Infrastructure development is prioritized as a cornerstone for economic growth. Substantial allocations to transportation and education signal a focus on improving critical sectors. For instance, the proposed ₦826 billion for education in 2025 aims to enhance literacy, skills acquisition, and workforce productivity. Similarly, ₦402 billion for healthcare seeks to improve health outcomes, directly impacting human capital development.
By focusing on curbing inflation, stabilizing exchange rates, and increasing oil production, Tinubu’s agenda aims to foster a conducive environment for domestic and foreign investment. The removal of fuel subsidies, though contentious, could save up to ₦5-6 trillion annually, potentially increasing state allocations by 70%. Furthermore, poverty reduction initiatives and social security provisions aim to cushion vulnerable populations against economic shocks. However, these measures have been criticized for their limited reach, underscoring the need for broader coverage.
Public resistance
The timing of these reforms, amidst significant economic hardships, has heightened public resistance and fears of worsening inequality. Public trust in the government’s ability to manage the reforms effectively remains low, complicating implementation.
The Nigeria Tax Bills have been a focal point of contention, sparking debates over its implications for regional equity and fiscal federalism. Speaking recently on behalf of the National Economic Council (NEC) led by Vice President Kashim Shettima, after its meeting at the Presidential Villa in Abuja, Governor Seyi Makinde of Oyo State stated: “After extensive deliberation, NEC noted the need for sufficient alignment among stakeholders for the proposed reforms. The council recommends withdrawing the bill currently before the National Assembly on tax reforms to allow for wider consultations and consensus building. This is necessary to address misinformation and clarify the vision for the country’s tax reform.”
Regional disparities and VAT distribution
Northern governors have criticized changes to VAT distribution, arguing that they favor wealthier southern states at the expense of economically weaker northern regions. To them, a derivation-based VAT model could exacerbate existing economic inequalities, undermining national cohesion. So, such critics also worry that proposed VAT increases and shifts in allocation could further impoverish northern states, reducing their capacity to fund essential services and infrastructure. Governor Babagana Zulum of Borno State initially expressed these concerns, stating: “We condemn these bills transmitted to the National Assembly. They will drag the North backward, and not only the North but also some southern states, including Oyo, Osun, Ekiti, and Ondo.”
The exclusion of labor unions, state governments, and private sector representatives from the reform process has further fueled resistance. Critics argue that this lack of inclusivity has led to policies that may not fully address on-ground realities.
Implications for Fiscal Federalism
The tax reforms’ perceived shift toward centralization threatens fiscal federalism, potentially reducing state autonomy and revenues. Opponents of the reforms fear that wealthier states like Lagos and Rivers will disproportionately benefit, leaving less affluent regions disadvantaged. While social intervention programmes exist, they are viewed as insufficient to counterbalance the adverse effects on vulnerable groups. Observers, therefore, emphasize the importance of inclusivity and transparency in fostering national consensus.
Outlook for 2025
The reforms are likely to dominate political discourse leading up to the 2025 elections, shaping party platforms and voter priorities. Their success or failure could significantly influence public perceptions of President Tinubu’s leadership and economic vision.
Key projections for 2025 include economic stabilization, increased revenue, and enhanced infrastructure and human capital development. Experts generally agree that Tinubu’s reform agenda represents a bold attempt to address Nigeria’s economic challenges. However, its success depends on balancing economic modernization with social inclusivity.
As the administration navigates these reforms, experts suggest that careful implementation and a focus on equitable development will be critical in determining their success and shaping Nigeria’s trajectory in 2025 and beyond.
READ ALSO: 2025 will consolidate Tinubu’s economic reforms — Information Minister
and then