Nigeria’s proposed tax reform bill, introduced by the Presidential Committee on Fiscal and Tax Reform chaired by Taiwo Oyedele, has stirred widespread debate.
The reform bill, which aims to streamline the tax system, includes harmonising multiple levies, unifying revenue collection processes, and integrating technology for greater efficiency.
At the centre of the proposal is a plan to adopt the derivation principle for the distribution of Value Added Tax (VAT) revenues.
Under this principle, VAT revenue would be distributed based on where goods and services are consumed rather than pooled centrally and redistributed.
ALSO READ: Southern states contribute N387.06bn to VAT pool — allocated N149.09bn in August 2024
Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) Chairman, Zacch Adedeji, explained the rationale by clarifying that VAT is fundamentally a consumption tax.
He stated, “On derivation, I see there is a mix-up here. We have the oil and gas. If you look at the oil and gas, where they produce is where we sell and collect money from the oil. That’s why it is limited to their States.
“VAT by definition is a consumption tax. If you use derivation in VAT, what it means is that where is it consumed. Where do you make the call? Where is the bank transaction done? What the bill seeks to correct is that the existing structure we have does not represent the intent of Nigeria.”
ALSO READ: FULL LIST: VAT generated in Lagos more than 35 other states, FCT combined in August 2024
While the reform aims to ensure fairer revenue distribution, it has met strong opposition from northern states.
Some Northern stakeholders argue that the contents of the proposed bill are against the interests of the North and other sub-nationals.
They claim that switching to a derivation model would unfairly favour economically dominant states, particularly Lagos, where most companies’ headquarters are located.
Tribune Online reports that recent data from FIRS highlights the disparity in VAT contributions and allocations.
In August 2024, Lagos State alone generated more VAT (N249.77 billion) than the combined total of 35 other states and the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) but only received N40.22 billion in allocation.
Meanwhile, ten northern states, which contributed a combined N13.69 billion, received a staggering N59.17 billion in allocations.
For instance, Zamfara State contributed N432.80 million but received N5.65 billion, while Katsina generated N1.68 billion and received N7.27 billion.
Below is the full list of what some northern states contributed to the VAT pool and what they benefitted (August 2024):
1. Zamfara
Contributed: N432.80m
Allocated: N5.65bn
2. Kebbi
Contributed: N665.17m
Allocated: N5.66bn
3. Bauchi
Contributed: N691.28m
Allocated: N6.48bn
4. Nasarawa
Contributed: N1.47bn
Allocated: N4.97bn
5. Jigawa
Contributed: N1.59bn
Allocated: N6.42bn
6. Katsina
Contributed: N1.68bn
Allocated: N7.27bn
7. Yobe
Contributed: N1.71bn
Allocated: N5.26bn
8. Niger
Contributed: N1.73bn
Allocated: N6.12bn
9. Sokoto
Contributed: N1.84bn
Allocated: N6.07bn
10. Taraba
Contributed: N1.88bn
Allocated: N5.27bn
Total contribution: 13.69 billion
Total allocation received: 59.17 billion
FULL LIST: 36 and FCT contributions and allocation from VAT pool in August 2024
Here is a full list of VAT generated and received from VAT pool by the 36 states and FCT in August 2024:
- Lagos
Contributed: N249.77bn
Allocation: N40.22bn
- Rivers:
Contributed: N70.54bn
Allocation: N15.54bn
- Oyo:
Contributed: N20.11bn
Allocation: N9.46bn
- FCT:
Contributed: N18.17bn
Allocation: N5.34bn
- Delta:
Contributed: N13.09bn
Allocation: N7.82bn
- Bayelsa:
Contributed: N7.12bn
Allocation: N5.58bn
- Kano:
Contributed: N4.65bn
Allocation: 9.71bn
- Akwa Ibom:
Contributed: N4.49bn
Allocation: N6.54bn
- Anambra:
Contributed: N4.28bn
Allocation: N6.66bn
- Edo:
Contributed: N4.05bn
Allocation: N6.08bn
- Ekiti:
Contributed: N3.66bn
Allocation: N5.54bn
- Borno:
Contributed: N3bn
Allocation: N6.48bn
- Kwara:
Contributed: N2.89bn
Allocation: N5.44bn
- Adamawa:
Contributed: N2.59bn
Allocation: N5.86b
- Plateau:
Contributed: N2.58bn
Allocation: N5.87bn
- Benue:
Contributed: N2.56bn
Allocation: N6.47bn
- Gombe:
Contributed: N2.55bn
Allocation: N5.38bn
- Kogi:
Contributed: N2.43bn
Allocation: N5.91bn
- Kaduna:
Contributed: N2.03bn
Allocation: N7.48bn
- Ebonyi:
Contributed: N1.90bn
Allocation: N5.20bn
- Taraba:
Contributed: N1.88bn
Allocation: N5.27bn
- Sokoto:
Contributed: N1.84bn
Allocation: N6.07bn
- Osun:
Contributed: N1.81bn
Allocation: N5.91bn
- Ogun:
Contributed: N1.74bn
Allocation: N6.08bn
- Niger:
Contributed: N1.73bn
Allocation: N6.21bn
- Yobe:
Contributed: N1.71bn
Allocation: N5.26bn
- Katsina:
Contributed: N1.68bn
Allocation: N7.27bn
- Jigawa:
Contributed: N1.59bn
Allocation: N6.42bn
- Nasarawa:
Contributed: N1.47bn
Allocation: N4.97bn
- Ondo:
Contributed: N1.45bn
Allocation: N5.88bn
- Enugu:
Contributed: N1.08bn
Allocation: N5.73bn
- Cross River:
Contributed: N1.08bn
Allocation: N5.51bn
- Bauchi:
Contributed: N691.28m
Allocation: N6.48bn
- Kebbi:
Contributed: N665.17m
Allocation: N5.66bn
- Abia:
Contributed: N663.42m
Allocation: N5.43bn
- Zamfara:
Contributed: N432.80m
Allocation: N5.65bn
37. Imo
Contributed: N235.41m
Allocation: N6.01bn
Total VAT Generated: N444.19bn
Total Allocation Distributed: N272.29bn
ALSO READ TOP STORIES FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE
WATCH TOP VIDEOS FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE TV
- Relationship Hangout: Public vs Private Proposals – Which Truly Wins in Love?
- “No” Is a Complete Sentence: Why You Should Stop Feeling Guilty
- Relationship Hangout: Friendship Talk 2025 – How to Be a Good Friend & Big Questions on Friendship
- Police Overpower Armed Robbers in Ibadan After Fierce Struggle
