Judge rules that man should be allowed to die because he does not want to live again

A judge in Britain has ruled that a sedated man in his 30s should be allowed to die rather than live the rest of his life with a stoma, the Daily Mail of UK reported.

The seriously ill patient who has suffered long-term bowel problems made clear his wishes before going into intensive care at Barnsley Hospital.

Following major surgery, specialists put his chances of survival between 60 and 70 per cent.

But they said he would need a permanent stoma – a surgical opening on the abdomen though which urine or faeces can be diverted out of the body.

The man had lived with a temporary stoma before and ‘hated it,’ his parents, who respect their son’s wishes, told Mr Justice Hayden during Monday’s Court of Protection hearing.

Speaking via videolink, his mother described how her son said: “How can I get a job? How can I get a woman?”

In a ruling published on Wednesday, the judge was told the man had made a written ‘advanced decision’ saying he would not want to live with a permanent stoma.

It is unlikely to be appealed as none of the litigants opposed carrying out the man’s wishes.

Bosses at Barnsley Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, who have responsibility for his care, had asked Mr Justice Hayden to decide what was in the man’s best interests.

They said a decision needed to be made because it would be some time before the man regained the capacity to make a decision for himself.

Mr Justice Hayden considered evidence on Monday at a virtual hearing in the Court of Protection, where judges consider issues about people who lack the mental capacity to make decisions for themselves.

He outlined his decision in a written ruling published on Wednesday.

The judge said medics could lawfully stop providing nutrition and hydration by artificial means to the man and move him to a palliative care regime.

Mr Justice Hayden said the man could not be identified in media reports of the case and referred to him by the initials ‘MSP’ in his ruling.

The man’s parents spoke to the judge at Monday’s hearing from their home, telling him their son had lived with a temporary stoma once before, following surgery.

Mr Justice Hayden said many people live ‘perfectly full lives’ with a stoma, but the man had delivered a ‘consistent’ message.

“Many people require a stoma to be fitted and I have no doubt that the vast majority make the necessary accommodations to ensure that it does not unnecessarily inhibit their enjoyment of life or become an impediment to their personal and sexual relationships,” said Mr Justice Hayden in his ruling.

“However, this was simply not the case with MSP. There is powerful evidence that as a young man in his 30s… MSP could never accept life with a stoma. No amount of support, love or understanding could change MSP’s mind.

“There is no doubt in my mind that he had come to a clear and entirely settled decision that he was not prepared to contemplate life with a stoma.”

The judge said the man had endured a ‘decade of serious ill health’ and had a ‘desperately reduced’ quality of life.

“His confidence and self-esteem has been adversely impacted,’ said the judge.

“His capacity to forge and maintain interpersonal relationships has been significantly eroded. He has made a practical, utilitarian calculation that life in these circumstances is not what he wants.

“In a real sense this is not a case about choosing to die, it is about an adult’s capacity to shape and control the end of his life.”

YOU SHOULD NOT MISS THESE HEADLINES FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE

Buy and read digital replicas of your TRIBUNE titles by subscribing through E-VENDING

Ministry Of Defence, Others Make Presentations As Buhari Presides Over Virtual FEC
President Muhammadu Buhari on Wednesday presided over the third virtual meeting of the Federal Executive Council (FEC) at the Council Chamber of the State House, Abuja. The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that the Ministries of Defence, Environment, Works and Housing as well as Finance, Budget and National… Read full story

How 19-Year-Old Barakat Was Allegedly Raped, Killed In Ibadan
Dejected, weary, Barakat’s mother, Mrs Kafayat Bello, lay on the floor mourning the loss of her daughter. Mrs Bello had returned on Monday evening to see her daughter lying in the pool of her own blood at the backyard of their home. Her 19-year old daughter had said to have been allegedly raped and killed by suspected… Read full story

Rivers, Cross River, Ondo, Osun, Bayelsa Get Refund Of N148bn Spent On Federal Roads, Bridges
The Federal Executive Council (FEC) at a virtual meeting presided over by President Muhammadu Buhari on Wednesday approved the refund of about N148,141,987,161.25 expended by five states to… Read full story