Court of Appeal adjourns hearing on Isara Remo kingship tussle till 2023

The Court of Appeal sitting in Ibadan has adjourned hearing on Odemo of Isara Remo kingship tussle till January 25, 2023

The 3-member panel of justices- Justices Yagatar Nimpar, Folasade Ojo and Abba Mohammed, premised the adjournment on a brief and application for regularization of papers filed by the Ogun State government, 11th to 15th respondents in the suit.

The appellant, Prince Samuel Odunsi had in the application filed before the Appellate Court faulted the ruling of the lower court that had earlier dismissed the suit challenging the installation of Oba Albert Mayungbe as Odemo of Isara Remo.

To this effect he had dragged the monarch; Secretary, Remo North Local Government; eight chiefs; Ogun State governor; Commissioner for Local Government and Attorney General and Commissioner for Justice before the Ogun State High Court, challenging Mayungbe’s selection and coronation.

He said the monarch’s selection was in error because he was an Odi by ancestry

His argument, Odi in Isara are those whose ancestral parents did not originate from the town, though they may have mixed with indigenes, including princes and princesses for centuries.

But the Ogun State High Court sitting in Sagamu dismissed the suit in a judgement delivered on March 29, 2018.

ALSO READ FROM NIGERIAN TRIBUNE 

• Anxiety Persists Over Terror Alert

• Umahi, Ayade’s Visit To Wike Fuels Speculation Of Alliance With APC

• VAR ‘doing a lot of damage,’ says Conte

• CBN Set To Release More $150m Foreign Airlines’ Trapped Funds

• Arsenal Pablo Mari stabbed in Italian supermarket

• EDITORIAL: Buhari: Drowning In Indifference

Odunsi had in his eight grounds of appeal, argued that the lower court erred in law in formulating and deciding on issues that were not implicated in parties’ pleadings on the custom and tradition of Remo land and those of Isara.

He submitted that the lower court erred by according credence to Mayungbe’s evidence and his witnesses at the expense of his own evidence, which he said was “incontrovertible,” being the position of the Akarigbo of Remo land.

ln a letter, Akarigbo, who is the paramount ruler of Remo land, had said it was an “unpardonable abomination” for an Odi to be crowned the Odemo of Isara, a position which he said necessitated his refusal to consent to Mayungbo’s selection.

Odunsi’s appeal also noted that the court erred by upholding a claim that one person can double as an Odi and a prince in spite of the evidence before the court.

It also said that the lower court erred by holding that Mayungbe is a member of Erinsiba/Ayoledoye ruling house.

However, the case could not be heard as scheduled on Thursday because the Ogun State Government, who is the 11th to 15th respondent in the suit, filed its brief and also applied to regularise its papers on Thursday morning.

Speaking to newsmen after the court session, Counsel to Odunsi, Adeniyi Aderogba, said there was no time to respond to Ogun State Government’s brief, because they were served few minutes before the court started sitting.

He said: “The matter actually came up on the 7th of June. On the 7th of June
peaking to newsmen after the court session, Counsel to Odunsi, Adeniyi Aderogba, said there was no time to respond to Ogun State Government’s brief, because they were served few minutes before the court started sitting.

He said: “The matter actually came up on the 7th of June. On the 7th of June, we regularised our papers. Unfortunately, Ogun State Government was not represented in court on that day. Ogun State Government is the 11th to 15th respondent.

The matter was adjourned till today, 27th of October, but unfortunately when we were in court, we were served with the brief filed by the 11th to 15th respondent, that is the Ogun State Government, together with an application to regularise their papers. Because the court has a duty to do substantial justice between the parties, the court in its magnanimity had to accommodate them.

The application was moved and granted and the court adjourned the matter to the 25th day of January for a hearing of the appeal. Just to mention that as the appellant’s counsel, under the rules, we have 15 days to file our reply brief in response to the Ogun State Government.

“We’ll certainly do that. We were not given the time because we were served few minutes before the court started sitting. So, we’ve not really been able to read the processes that Ogun State Government filed.

“But I assure you that before the next date, we would have filed everything so that the hearing of the appeal and go on. We just hope that the court will sit on the 25th of January so that the appeal can go on.”

Also speaking, counsel to the first respondent, Mayungbe, and eight of the chiefs, Dr Victor Odunaiya, said he came to argue the appeal, but the motion was not taken.

“It was the first application we came to argue today and the appeal was the appellant’s motion, which was dated 21st of October. But that one was not taken today again.

“The second application by the Ogun State Government, that one was filed today and was heard today. I won’t say more,” Odunaiya said.